It may sound like something straight out of political fan fiction: Donald Trump facing Barack Obama in a presidential election. But a recent survey has given Americans a chance to weigh in on how they would vote if such a matchup ever occurred in 2028.
While legally impossible due to the 22nd Amendment, which limits presidents to two terms, the idea has captured the imagination of the public and the media alike. According to a poll conducted by Daily Mail and J.L. Partners, which surveyed 1,013 registered voters across the United States, Barack Obama would have an edge over Donald Trump in a hypothetical matchup.
The results showed that 52% of respondents would vote for Obama, while 41% would choose Trump. Breaking the results down demographically, the poll revealed strong support for Obama among minority groups. Seventy-three percent of Hispanic voters said they would back Obama, while 68% of Black voters indicated the same preference.
These figures suggest that Obama’s appeal remains particularly strong within communities that have historically supported Democratic candidates. Perhaps most notably, Obama was the only recent Democratic figure to outperform Trump in these hypothetical polls.
When other prominent Democrats, such as Hillary Clinton or Kamala Harris, were included in similar head-to-head scenarios, Trump led. This makes the Obama vs. Trump scenario unique and especially intriguing, even if it exists only in the realm of “what if.” The historical context adds another layer of fascination.
Barack Obama first won the presidency in 2008 and secured reelection in 2012, making him one of the most influential political figures of the past two decades. Donald Trump, on the other hand, won an unexpected victory in 2016, lost the 2020 election to Joe Biden, and returned to the White House in 2024. Together, these two men have defined American politics for nearly 20 years, yet they have never gone head-to-head at the ballot box.
The public’s curiosity is fueled in part by Trump’s repeated hints about a potential third term. In April, Trump was asked how he would feel about running against Obama if it were legally possible. He responded enthusiastically: “I’d love that. That would be a good one. I’d like that.”
Trump went on to acknowledge that while there are ideas circulating about how a third term could theoretically occur, he has not seriously explored them. He emphasized his focus on completing his current term, which still had nearly four years to go at the time of the interview.
Earlier in the year, in an interview with NBC News, Trump again addressed the speculation about a third term. He noted that many supporters encouraged him to consider it but stressed that it was too early to think about such a scenario. “I like working,” he said with a grin. “I’m not joking, but it is far too early to think about it. There are methods through which you could do it.” These comments, while playful, have kept the conversation alive and encouraged widespread discussion about what a Trump-Obama contest might look like, even as the legal impossibility looms.
The poll results suggest that, in a purely hypothetical matchup, Obama would enjoy a notable advantage. His continued popularity among key demographics, combined with his legacy as a transformative president, appears to give him an edge over Trump.
The survey also underscores the stark polarization of American politics: while Obama dominates among minority voters, Trump retains strong support among other demographic groups, demonstrating that the country remains deeply divided along political and cultural lines.
Legally, however, a Trump-Obama matchup in 2028 is almost impossible. The U.S. Constitution’s 22nd Amendment limits presidents to two terms. Overturning this restriction would require approval from two-thirds of both the House of Representatives and the Senate, followed by ratification from at least 38 state legislatures—a process that is extraordinarily difficult and highly unlikely.
Yet, in today’s unpredictable political climate, no scenario can be entirely dismissed. Trump’s public hints, combined with Obama’s silence on the issue, ensure that the idea will continue to provoke curiosity, speculation, and debate among Americans.
Even if it remains purely hypothetical, the notion of a Trump vs. Obama election captures the imagination because it pits two of the most consequential and recognizable political figures of the past twenty years against each other.
Their legacies, leadership styles, and visions for the country could not be more different, making this “what if” scenario a fascinating thought experiment for voters, analysts, and political observers alike. Whether it ever happens or not, it is a reminder of how much influence these two men have had on American politics—and how much Americans continue to imagine what could have been.