New poll reveals how Americans really feel about Melania Trump compared to other first ladies

Melania Trump’s second tenure as First Lady of the United States has mirrored the turbulent trajectory of her husband’s administration: a high-stakes “roller coaster” defined by a deliberate, often impenetrable privacy. While she remains a fixture of the global stage, she has largely retreated from the traditional visibility of the East Wing. Now, fresh polling data is pulling back the curtain on how the American public evaluates her performance compared to the historical giants who preceded her.

Before reclaiming her title in January 2025, the Slovenian-born former model signaled that her second act in Washington would break tradition. Melania has largely delivered on that promise, dividing her time between the White House, her New York residence, and Mar-a-Lago, all while maintaining her signature Be Best initiative. However, the true centerpiece of her return has been a cinematic one.

The $40 Million “Experience”

Shortly before Donald Trump’s second inauguration, Melania announced the production of a documentary chronicling her re-entry into public life. In a move that stunned the industry, Amazon reportedly paid $40 million for the filming rights—a record-shattering sum for a commissioned documentary. Released this past January, the film has faced a polarized reception from critics, even as Melania herself maintains its success is personal.

“I’m very proud of the film, so people may like it, may don’t like it, and that’s their choice,” she told CNN shortly before the premiere. “We achieved what we want to achieve. For myself, it’s already successful.”

The Numbers: A Net-Negative Approval

While the President navigates fluctuating polls ahead of the upcoming midterms, a comprehensive YouGov poll conducted between February 2 and 5, 2026, offers a sobering baseline for the First Lady’s standing. The survey, which reached 2,255 adult citizens, revealed that Melania holds a -16 net approval rating.

While this figure places her below her immediate predecessor, Jill Biden (-9), she remains slightly more popular than Hillary Clinton, who polled at -17.

Net Approval Ratings: A Historical Comparison

The contrast between the current First Lady and her predecessors is stark, as many historical figures retain high double-digit favorability:

The Polarized Divide

Unsurprisingly, the data highlights a chasm in partisan perception. Melania’s support remains robust among Republican voters, where her approval significantly outpaces her standing with Democrats and Independents. This polarization reflects the broader political climate, where the role of the First Lady has increasingly become a lightning rod for partisan sentiment.

Despite the negative net rating, Melania continues to focus on her “purposeful storytelling,” betting that her documentary and selective public appearances will eventually shift the needle in her favor.